Carlos Sainz has put an end to all the rumors and speculation about his future by signing with Williams. But was it the right move? Our experts weigh in.
On the surface, Sainz’s options for the 2025 Formula 1 season were limited. With Williams and Sauber/Audi at the bottom of the constructors’ championship and Alpine facing management upheaval, the choices weren’t exactly enticing. However, there are positives to Sainz’s decision.
Williams has faced significant challenges, including delays in car design that left their FW46 overweight. But these issues are unlikely to repeat, potentially offering an instant lap time improvement. While not at Ferrari’s winning level, Williams’ current car shows promise for scoring points occasionally.
Meanwhile, Sauber is dealing with its own management crisis. Andreas Seidl has been replaced by Mattia Binotto, who was later axed. Sainz’s former boss at McLaren, Seidl’s departure adds another layer of uncertainty. At Williams, James Vowles remains a steady leader, and securing Sainz’s signature likely pleased the team’s owners.
Let’s not forget the options that weren’t on the table. Red Bull, with its history with the Sainz family, seemed unlikely. Mercedes appeared set on promoting Andrea Kimi Antonelli from Formula 2, leaving no room for Sainz. Alpine’s stop in engine production also made Williams more appealing for 2025.
However, the timing of Sainz’s decision is puzzling. With the driver market still in flux, why not wait? What if Red Bull or Mercedes reconsidered? Could Sainz have landed a seat in a top team? Nevertheless, he’s now with a team with a storied history and a promising future.
Sainz will be teaming up with Alex Albon, creating an intriguing driver lineup. While some might think Sainz jumped the gun, there’s no doubt he’ll be a valuable asset for Williams.
Time will tell if Carlos Sainz made the right move by signing with Williams. One thing is clear: his decision has certainly spiced up the driver market and added a new dynamic to the Formula 1 grid.
